Coil vs. Strip Nail Guns: Which to Use for Roofing

Coil vs. Strip Nail Guns for Roofing

Coil Nailers

Coil nailers hold 200 to 350 nails in a circular magazine. For roofing, they dramatically reduce the number of reloads on a large run of shingles.

Pros: Less frequent reloading, lighter magazine weight when full coil depletes, familiar to most roofing crews.

Cons: Larger magazine can snag on steep pitches, coils are more expensive per nail than strips.

Strip Nailers

Strip nailers hold 60 to 80 nails per strip. They are narrower and easier to maneuver in tight spots (valleys, dormers, near flashing).

Pros: Lower initial cost, easier access in confined areas, strips are widely stocked at any lumber yard.

Cons: More frequent reloads on high-production days.

Nail Specs for Asphalt Shingles

• Minimum shank diameter: 12 gauge (0.105 in) per IBC Section 1507.2
• Minimum head diameter: 3/8 in
• Length: 1-3/4 in for new decking, 2 in over existing shingles
• Hot-dipped galvanized or stainless for coastal environments

Bottom Line

For production roofing (1,500+ sq ft), coil nailers win on speed. For detail work and small repairs, strip nailers offer better control. Many crews own both.